fbpx Criticism | HowlRound Theatre Commons

Criticism

Here, you’ll find content about the art and practice of theatre criticism. Many pieces grapple with questions of how to diversify the field, making it more accessible for young people, queer folx, and critics of color. This section also contains all the pieces of criticism in the Journal, which we call “NewCrits.” NewCrits analyze productions and go beyond “thumbs up, thumbs down” reviews, placing the work(s) in question in a larger, broader context—whether that’s the context of the time or place it’s done in, the artists’ body of work, or its genre. Are you interested in writing a NewCrit? Check out our guidelines and best practices!

The Latest

Consent, Courtship, and Comedy in Keiko Green’s The Bed Trick
Essay
Consent, Courtship, and Comedy in Keiko Green’s The Bed Trick
by Erin Murray
21 May 2024
On Between Two Knees, or About Other Futures
Essay
On Between Two Knees, or About Other Futures
by Sebastián Eddowes-Vargas
17 April 2024
Viewpoints for Achieving Authentic Representation of Roma Communities on Stage
Essay
Viewpoints for Achieving Authentic Representation of Roma Communities on Stage
by Tímea Éva Bogya, Márton Illés
27 March 2024
The Brain in the Crown
Essay

The Brain in the Crown

David Adjmi’s Marie Antoinette and Smart Entertainment

17 May 2015

Rob Onorato on Steppenwolf Theatre’s production of Marie Antoinette by David Adjmi.

The Vanguard
Essay

The Vanguard

Oral History-Driven Monologues on the Lower East Side

12 May 2015

Emma Wiseman on three “East Side Stories,” verbatim monologues at the Metropolitan Playhouse.

Should Torture Taste So Good? Belarus Free Theatre’s Trash Cuisine
Essay

Should Torture Taste So Good? Belarus Free Theatre’s Trash Cuisine

7 May 2015

Jonathan Mandell on Belarus Free Theatre's Trash Cuisine, playing through May 17 at La Mama ETC in New York City.

Remember Chavez Ravine! A Los Angeles Story
Essay

Remember Chavez Ravine! A Los Angeles Story

5 May 2015

David G. Garcia and Alma Itzé Flores on the 2015 revival of Culture Clash's Chavez Ravine at Center Theatre Group in Los Angeles, California. 

Developmental Through Lines
Essay

Developmental Through Lines

O’Neill, The Nether, and Bright Half Life

28 April 2015

The author ruminates on two plays that recently concluded Off Broadway runs and their early development at the O’Neill Playwrights Conference. 

Technicolor Broadway
Essay

Technicolor Broadway

On The Town, Gigi, and An American in Paris

23 April 2015

The author on three musicals that have opened on Broadway this season, all descended from movie musicals that the MGM movie studio made in the Technicolor era. 

Carlos Morton Resurrects Oscar Zeta Acosta in Brown Buffalo
Essay

Carlos Morton Resurrects Oscar Zeta Acosta in Brown Buffalo

16 April 2015

The author explores Company of Angels' workshop production of Dr. Morton's “heavy and psychedelic play.”

On Richard Maxwell & the Rupture of Real
Essay

On Richard Maxwell & the Rupture of Real

14 April 2015

The author on The Kitchen's production of The Evening by Richard Maxwell. 

I Fall in Love All the Time
Essay

I Fall in Love All the Time

9 April 2015

The author shares her thoughts on Gideon Irving and the Foundry Theatre’s Living Here: a map of songs.

Are Theatre Critics Critical? An Update
Essay

Are Theatre Critics Critical? An Update

1 April 2015

Frequent contributor Jonathan Mandell considers the current condition of theatre criticism and theatre critics.

Grounded
Essay

Grounded

A Stunning Singular Strike at Olney Theatre

31 March 2015

George Brant’s Grounded, at Olney Theatre, is a fast-paced, suspenseful, and moving one-woman show about a drone operator’s struggle to play two roles: annihilator and mother.

Are Criticism Rating Systems Serving Anybody?
Essay

Are Criticism Rating Systems Serving Anybody?

29 March 2015

Director Joanie Schultz talks to theatre critics and theatre artists about critic rating systems.

Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’ An Octoroon
Essay

Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’ An Octoroon

26 March 2015

The author explores playwright Branden Jacobs-Jenkins adaptation of The Octoroon, called An Octoroon, and its depiction of race and gender onstage. 

Los Empeños de una Casa at GALA Hispanic Theatre
Essay

Los Empeños de una Casa at GALA Hispanic Theatre

24 March 2015

Patricia Davis on House of Desires by Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz produced in Spanish with English surtitles by GALA (Grupo de Artistas Latinoamericanos) Hispanic Theatre in Washington D.C. 

Reflecting on Twenty-Seven Years of Shear Madness at the Kennedy Center
Essay

Reflecting on Twenty-Seven Years of Shear Madness at the Kennedy Center

19 March 2015

Ronee Penoi on Shear Madness, the longest running play in the American Theatre. 

TEDxBroadway 2015
Essay

TEDxBroadway 2015

Ten Lessons Theatre Can Learn from Golf, Knishes, Teens, Tevye, and Twitter, But Not Termites

8 March 2015

The question from TEDxBroadway 2015: What ideas about theatre can we learn from people who may never have been inside one?

Hamilton
Essay

Hamilton

Five Ways Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Hip-Hopped History Musical Breaks New Ground

5 March 2015

There is a sense that this piece somehow transcends theatre even as it embodies it—or, as Hamilton puts it: “This is not a moment, it’s a movement.”

The Long Shadow of Marble Busts
Essay

The Long Shadow of Marble Busts

12 February 2015

Brett Bailey’s Exhibit B poses actors in tableau vivants that nod to 19th century human zoos, and Southwest African concentration camps. Patrick Gaughan charts the controversy around the show and his own experience of it. 

Audience Participation
Essay

Audience Participation

Do Taylor Mac et al Tickle or Terrify?

5 February 2015

"Audience participation" is a vague term, like much of theatrical terminology; it has come to mean different things to different people... What happens when the audience participates by becoming performers—without volunteering to do so?

“The most gorgeous group of f*ck ups” in Airline Highway at Steppenwolf
Essay

“The most gorgeous group of f*ck ups” in Airline Highway at Steppenwolf

3 February 2015

Airline Highway is about community. D’Amour focuses the play not on their pain, but on their joy and celebration of a life fully lived, using the “living funeral” as a landscape to highlight her nuanced characters and their complex relationships.

Your Average Obsessive
Essay

Your Average Obsessive

From the Superhuman to the Simply Human

28 December 2014

Sarah Orem explores the often-humorous way OCD is treated in mainstream film and television, and then shares three different examples of how theater treats the illness with honesty.

The New Freak Shows
Essay

The New Freak Shows

11 December 2014

Are we free to gawk again? That’s what Broadway audiences are doing during the revival of The Elephant Man, one of several stage shows and television series that are bringing attention back to the freak show.

Photo from How We Got On.
Forum Theatre’s How We Got On
Essay

Forum Theatre’s How We Got On

9 December 2014

Though set in 1988, the play’s insistence on the power of words, creativity, and voice as a means of self-assertion, growth, and transformation is of timeless importance and is especially relevant now.

Photo from Forgotten Future: The Education Project.
Broken Public Schools and Community Dialogue at Collaboraction
Essay

Broken Public Schools and Community Dialogue at Collaboraction

4 December 2014

Based on interviews with local teachers and students about the current educational climate, Forgotten Futures creates space for discussion of the dysfunction plaguing Chicago Public Schools.

Photo from Zoetrope: Part 1.
Caborca Theatre’s Zoetrope
Essay

Caborca Theatre’s Zoetrope

Part 1

2 December 2014

Carol Kearns writes about Zoetrope: Part 1, a drama set in 1951 Puerto Rico, looking at its multimedia aesthetic, bilingual presentation, and political themes.